Santa Cruz vs. Monterey home prices
In October 2026 the median sale price of an existing single-family home was $1,275,000 in Santa Cruz County, unchanged from a year earlier, and $980,000 in Monterey County, down 3.4%, according to the California Association of REALTORS®. That is a gap of almost $300,000 between the two counties.
The county numbers hide big differences. Monterey County includes Salinas and the Salinas Valley as well as Carmel-by-the-Sea and Pebble Beach, where prices are far higher than the county median. Santa Cruz County ranges from Watsonville to the beach neighborhoods of Santa Cruz and Capitola. Here is how some of the towns compare:
| Santa Cruz County | Median sale price | Monterey County | Median sale price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Santa Cruz | $1,424,009 | Monterey | $1,094,239 |
| Capitola | $1,468,978 | Pacific Grove | $1,424,009 |
| Scotts Valley | $1,166,189 | Carmel-by-the-Sea | $2,833,029 |
| Aptos | $1,090,741 | Seaside | $784,454 |
| Watsonville | $709,506 | Salinas | $734,489 |
Town figures: Redfin housing market data, all home types, three months ending October 2026.
To put any two towns side by side, use the compare tool, or read the Santa Cruz County and Monterey County guides.
Size and feel: a beach town vs. a harbor town
At the 2020 Census, the city of Santa Cruz had about 63,000 residents and the city of Monterey about 30,000. Santa Cruz is busier and younger, shaped by UC Santa Cruz, the Santa Cruz Beach Boardwalk, downtown's Pacific Avenue and its surf breaks. It has a strong arts and live music scene and a famously independent streak.
Monterey is smaller and quieter, built around its harbor, Cannery Row, Fisherman's Wharf and the Monterey Bay Aquarium. It was California's capital under Spain and Mexico, and Colton Hall, where the state's first constitution was written in 1849, still stands downtown. The Naval Postgraduate School and the Defense Language Institute give it a long military and language-school presence.
The coastline: beaches, surf and wildlife
- Santa Cruz is a surf town. Steamer Lane and Pleasure Point are among the best-known surf spots in California, West Cliff Drive runs along the cliffs to Natural Bridges State Beach, and the Beach Boardwalk, opened in 1907, is California's oldest surviving seaside amusement park. See the surfing guide.
- Monterey is built for the water in a different way: diving and kayaking in the calm water off Cannery Row, whale watching from the harbor, and sea otters in the kelp. Point Lobos, Carmel Beach and the 17-Mile Drive through Pebble Beach are minutes away, and the Big Sur coast starts just south of Carmel. See the guides to scuba diving and whale watching.
Between the two, Moss Landing and Elkhorn Slough are one of the best places on the Central Coast to see sea otters.
Redwoods, trails and the outdoors
Santa Cruz backs up to the Santa Cruz Mountains and their redwood forests: Henry Cowell Redwoods State Park is in Felton, and Big Basin Redwoods State Park, California's oldest state park, is above Boulder Creek. Mountain biking, hiking and trail running are part of daily life. See the mountain biking guide.
Monterey leans toward the Monterey Peninsula's coastal trails, Fort Ord Dunes and the open hills of Fort Ord National Monument, the oak and vineyard country of Carmel Valley, and the Santa Lucia Mountains above Big Sur. Golf is a bigger part of life on the Monterey side, with Pebble Beach and the courses around it. See the golf guide.
How far apart are Santa Cruz and Monterey, and how do you get around?
- Santa Cruz to Monterey. The two are about 40 miles apart on Highway 1, which runs along the bay past Watsonville and through Moss Landing. Without traffic the drive is usually under an hour.
- To the Bay Area and Silicon Valley. Santa Cruz connects to San Jose, about 30 miles away, over the Santa Cruz Mountains on Highway 17. From Monterey, the usual route north is Highway 1 to Highway 156 and U.S. 101, a longer drive.
- Flying. Monterey has its own airport, Monterey Regional, with commercial flights. Santa Cruz residents usually fly out of San Jose.
Things to do: Santa Cruz vs. Monterey
- Santa Cruz: the Beach Boardwalk and its Giant Dipper roller coaster, the wharf, downtown shops and music venues, surfing, farmers markets, wineries in the Santa Cruz Mountains, and UC Santa Cruz events. See arts and live music.
- Monterey: the Monterey Bay Aquarium, Cannery Row (named for John Steinbeck's novel), Fisherman's Wharf, historic adobes downtown, the Monterey Jazz Festival each September, and the restaurants and galleries of Carmel-by-the-Sea. See events and festivals.
Visiting both? A simple day trip from Santa Cruz to Monterey follows Highway 1: coffee in Capitola, otters at Moss Landing, lunch on Cannery Row, the aquarium, and a sunset drive along 17-Mile Drive or in Carmel. It is a good way to see which side of the bay feels like home.
Schools and colleges
Santa Cruz is home to UC Santa Cruz and, nearby in Aptos, Cabrillo College. The Monterey area has CSU Monterey Bay nearby, along with Monterey Peninsula College, the Middlebury Institute of International Studies and the Naval Postgraduate School. For K-12 schools, each community guide on this site lists public schools by town, with links to the state's school data. Public school districts include Santa Cruz City Schools on the Santa Cruz side and Monterey Peninsula Unified, Pacific Grove Unified and Carmel Unified on the Monterey Peninsula.
Santa Cruz or Monterey: how to decide
- Choose Santa Cruz if you want a lively beach town, surf and redwoods out the door, a university-town feel, and the shortest drive to Silicon Valley.
- Choose Monterey if you want a quieter harbor town with history, an airport close by, easy access to Carmel, Pebble Beach and Big Sur, and somewhat lower prices in many neighborhoods.
- Spend a weekday and a weekend in each. Drive your likely commute at the time you would actually drive it.
- Compare recent sales for the kind of home you want, not just the county medians.
I work on both sides of the bay and can show you homes in Santa Cruz County and Monterey County. Call or text me at (831) 515-8133.

